space
Reader Reviews | |
Review by Chrissi (190103) Rating (8/10) Review
by Chrissi It all starts with Ross Ericsson, a lecturer at Cabrillo University, a small college trying for, and getting, an ex-military supercomputer (Simon) on the basis that they wish to use it to investigate the ability of an artificially intelligent being to learn language. As an artificial intelligence, the commands used to tell the computer what to do need to be kept deliberately vague in order that it isn’t limited in any way. This lack of limitation means that they effectively did not tell the computer that they wanted it to concentrate on human language, so when it starts listening to the dolphins in the nearby aquatic park, it not only learns dolphin communication but is able to speak to them. It is a very eloquent book, we see how the college acquire the computer and the background that allows for the interaction between man, computer and dolphins. The story is reasonably complicated, because we see not only the college people and their stories, but also we meet a not very nice man, the man who would subvert the developing relationship between the men and the dolphins. I suppose that people like that exist in literary tomes just as they exist in real life, because they make us appreciate that not everyone is nice, and sometimes nice people are thrown up against the not-so-nice in order that they become better people. The people in the story are nice, there is no doubt about it, but they are not particularly well fleshed out. This is not a harsh criticism, because they are all equally well finished, and theirs are not really the main themes of the book, but I did not feel particularly attached to them at the end of the story. Maybe it was just because I was so enchanted by the development of the relationship with the dolphins, that in contrast I paid less attention to the humans. It would seem that the wisdom of the dolphins is kept alive by the telling, and the whole of history is available to them from their own watery perspective. This is a really interesting idea, but when the people become aware of this, they ask when was the Suez Canal opened, a watery enough question I would have thought, the dolphins answer with the correct year, this confused me somewhat, given the fact that they would be aware of years, but the beginning of the Christian calendar would surely be of no interest to them. It is not made clear quite how much of the dialogue is being interpreted by the computer and so I’m assuming this information is provided by Simon based on what the dolphins are actually saying. However, this is really just a small niggle that, if accepted, isn’t a problem. I understand from the blurb that the author is an ex-naval person, and it really shows in his knowledge of the sea and scuba diving. He would seem to have a wide-ranging knowledge of the lore surrounding the oceans, with shipwrecks and stories of Atlantis, he has brought all of this to his book, and mixed it all up in an extraordinary way. I would be curious to know what he will come up with next.
I would heartily recommend this book to anyone, it is really quite
an intriguing idea that RG Roane has come up with, and it left
me with a really nice feeling. It would be a shame for me to give
away too much of the story, because the revelations of the dolphins
would be better off within the structure of the book, but it was
so nice that the story ends with a huge benefit to mankind, beyond
being able to talk with another sentient species. |
|
Column Ends |
space